Spoiler effect

A federal judge has reportedly thrown out the Justice Department lawsuit filed at President Trump's direction seeking to delay certification of Alaska's Senate race, which pits GOP Sen. Dan Sullivan against Democrat Mary Peltola. Alaska's attorney general had called the suit "meritless," and the dispute centers on a spoiler candidate also named Dan Sullivan, reportedly recruited by Peltola staffers to confuse ranked-choice voters; some voters have said they were genuinely unsure which "Dan Sullivan" they chose. Sullivan said he will accept the results regardless, while Peltola has denied involvement in the recruitment scheme. Judge Sharon L. Gleason presided over the case.

A federal investigation into alleged "ballot stacking" in Alaska's U.S. Senate race centers on Petersburg, the fishing town where Dan J. Sullivan, a former teacher who entered the race against Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, lives. FBI agents have questioned about a dozen residents who donated to Dan J. Sullivan's roughly $7,150 campaign, asking whether they felt deceived and whether they had meant to donate to the senator instead. Sullivan has not been seen publicly for weeks and has denied coordinating with Democrats or Mary Peltola's campaign, though a New York Times report detailed a Peltola-linked effort to recruit Alaskans named Dan Sullivan. A Trump administration lawsuit seeking to block certification of the election was dismissed, then appealed. The case, tied to Alaska's open primary and ranked-choice system, could affect control of the Senate.

In Petersburg, Alaska, retired teacher Dan J. Sullivan's campaign against Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, once dismissed as a prank dubbed "Decoy Dan," has become a federal investigation. FBI agents have visited and interviewed about a dozen local donors who gave roughly $7,150 combined, asking whether they felt deceived and whether they meant to donate to the incumbent instead. Dan J. Sullivan has not been seen publicly for weeks, and reporters have been unable to reach him. The Trump administration is weighing "ballot stacking" charges, and a Justice Department lawsuit seeking to block certification of the race was dismissed, then appealed. Democrat Mary Peltola denies any role after reports linked allies to decoy-candidate recruitment in the tight Senate race.

A New York Times report alleges top aides to Alaska Democrat Mary Peltola searched voter rolls in 2025 for a resident named Dan Sullivan, hoping to recruit one to run against Republican incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan and split his support under the state's ranked-choice system. The effort, reportedly run by operative Jerid Kurtz with DSCC coordination, found retired teacher Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. in Petersburg, who entered the race; both Sullivans now appear on the four-person ballot, distinguished by middle initial, "Jr.," party affiliation, and an "Incumbent" label. Peltola's campaign and the DSCC deny involvement, calling the report a "distraction," though a fired former campaign manager told the Times Peltola was "definitely aware."

Gov. Mike Dunleavy directed Alaska's Department of Public Safety to investigate whether the scheme violated state law, saying the report shows an "organized effort" to confuse voters. The order follows Trump's call for Peltola's prosecution and a DOJ lawsuit seeking to block certification of a Peltola win if Sullivan Jr. stays on the ballot. Dunleavy has since suggested the state could withhold or delay certifying the Senate results if Peltola wins, pending the probe's findings, and the House Oversight Committee has opened its own inquiry. Sullivan Jr. denies coordinating with Democrats, and the Alaska Supreme Court previously allowed him to remain on the ballot; a legal analyst notes recruiting a spoiler candidate, even if true, may not be illegal under Alaska law.

Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy has directed the Department of Public Safety to investigate allegations that staff for Democratic Senate candidate Mary Peltola and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee recruited namesake challenger Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. to siphon votes from Republican incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan. The probe follows New York Times reporting, partly based on a since-retracted account from Peltola's fired former campaign manager, Elisa Rios, describing an internal "ballot composition" effort allegedly involving Peltola's campaign lawyers and senior DSCC aides. The Peltola campaign and DSCC deny involvement, with Peltola calling the controversy "a distraction"; the retired Petersburg teacher also denies running at Democrats' behest, though he has acknowledged a history of backing Peltola and other Democrats.

President Trump called for Peltola's prosecution and removal from the ballot, and the Justice Department has issued fresh subpoenas to Democratic officials believed to be involved in the recruitment effort, building on an existing U.S. Attorney's Office inquiry into Daniel J. Sullivan dating back to summer. The DOJ has also sued to block certification if Sullivan narrowly loses, arguing the scheme amounts to a "conspiracy to undermine the integrity of the electoral process"; Alaska moved to dismiss that suit, calling it meritless, and a federal judge set an expedited schedule with a ruling possible within days. The Alaska Supreme Court previously rejected efforts to remove the challenger Sullivan from the ballot. Sen. Lisa Murkowski joined other Republicans condemning the alleged scheme as voters rank Sen. Sullivan, Peltola, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., and Gerald Heikes on the Nov. 3 ballot.

Dunleavy has declined to commit to certifying the election if Peltola wins while the investigation is ongoing, saying any finding of illegal conduct "may in fact impact whether somebody is seated in the U.S. Senate" and that officials would weigh whether to involve Senate leadership. House Oversight Committee Chair James Comer has demanded testimony from operatives named in the reporting and threatened subpoenas of his own. Dunleavy's term ends Dec. 7, shortly after Alaska's target date for certifying results.

Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy has directed the state's Department of Public Safety to investigate Democrat Mary Peltola's Senate campaign following a New York Times report alleging her team helped recruit a candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., sharing a name with her Republican rival, incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan, to split his votes. The probe will examine whether the scheme violated state law. Peltola's campaign and the DSCC deny involvement with the decoy candidate; Peltola called the report a "distraction." President Trump demanded prosecution and removal of both from the ballot, while Vice President Vance called for a fraud investigation. The Alaska Supreme Court previously ruled Sullivan Jr. eligible to remain on the ballot.

The controversy intensifies a closely watched Senate race pivotal to chamber control, with the Justice Department already suing to block certification if Peltola wins while the second Sullivan remains on the ballot.